Tuesday, March 18, 2014

What is Right Knowledge and Why should we care?

(This is a continuation of the previous Blog post 'Bhagawad Gita - What is in it for you')


Why gain 'Right Knowledge'?

Sri Krishna starts the Bhagawad Gita giving a very clear indication of what happens when one lacks right knowledge and perspectives:

asochyaan anya sochyastwam
prajnaa vaadaamcha bhaashase”  B.G Ch .2 Verse 11)

In the absence of right knowledge and perspectives one would "grieve upon what not be grieved about and become eloquent in justifying the grief arising out of delusion".  Therefore in the absence of right knowledge we will become overly concerned about what we shouldn’t be concerning about and as a result get mired in unnecessary confusion

What is 'Right Knowledge'

There are three components for 'right Knowledge'. They are addressed in the different chapters of Bhagawad Gita as below.
Let us take a deeper look into each one of the above.

What is the real nature of self?

Sri Krishna initially uses the sanskrit word 'dehi' , meaning the one who occupies the body of a living being, to refer to the self. Later on he uses the word 'kshetranja' , meaning the 'knower of the field' to refer to the same. And finally, he uses the term 'aatma' to refer to self, meaning the single, undivided presence that appears as soul in all living beings. The key point to note is that the real nature of self is not even the 'I' consciousness but the pure presence that enlivens the body-mind complex, which is described in Vedanta as 'existence, knowledge and bliss' (Sat-Chit-Aananda)

"dehi nityam avadhyoyam
dehe sarvasya bhaarata" B.G Ch. 2 Verse 30

"The soul that occupies the body of living beings is eternal and imperishable"

"achedyoyam adaahyoyam
akledyo soshya eva cha
nitya sarvagata sthaanu
achaloyam sanaatanah
avyaktoyam achinthyoyam
avikaaryoyam uvhyate" " B.G Ch. 2 Verse 24 & 25

"(This soul that is) indestructible by weapons as well as fire, water or wind, is eternal, all pervading, unchanging, unmoved (transcends space) and ancient (transcends time). This self that is not available for sensory perception, nor  the conception of the mind is said to never undergo any modifications"

upadrashtaanumanthaa cha
bhartaa bhoktaa maheswarah
paramaatmeti chaapyukto
dehesmin purusha parah  B.G Ch 13 Verse 23

"This indweller of body is in fact transcendental and is referred to as the supreme self (pramaatma) who the same time that he is the Lord, the cause, the ruler and the enjoyer of the field of experience remains as an unaffected witness to it"

The above, in summary, is Bhagawad Gita's view on the nature of self.


Who is Ishvara (God) and  what is his nature?

All through Bhagawad Gita, Sri Krishna is addressed as 'Bhagavaan' and his words are identified as 'Bhagavaan uvaacha', 'thus spoke Bhagavaan'. The literal translation of the Sanskrit word Bhagavaan  is 'the resplendent one'. But there is also a deeper explanation for this word, which is 'one who knows about the emergence and dissolution of the created world'. The 'ishwara'  of Bhagawad Gita is the permanence that transcends the impermanence of the creation.

ethad yonini bhutaani
sarvaanityupadhaaraya
aham krisnasya jagathah
prabhava pralyasthadaa"  B.G Ch 7 Verse 6

"This (Ishwara) is the origin for all the beings and as in it are they sustained. I am everything in this world including their emergence and dissolution"

mattha paratharam naanyathu
kinchidasthi dhananjaya
mayi sarvamidam protham
sutre maniganaa iva"    B.G ch 7 Verse 7

"O Dhanajaya, there is nothing that exists beyond me. In me are all these  strung, like the beads on a necklace"

Now, a question can come up as to whether the Ishwara is an insentient principle from which all these has come.  To alleviate this doubt, Krishna describes his nature as:

gatir bhartaa prabhu saakshi
nivaasa saranam suhrut
prabhava pralayasthaanam
nidhaanam bheejam avyayam    B.G Ch 9 Verse 18

"(Ishwara is) the path (of spiritual evolution), the upholder (of the universe), the Lord (who is enforcer of the rules),  the eternal witness (to passage of time), the place of rest, the refuge and the benignant friend (to the seeker). (Ishwara is)  the place of origin, place of existence and the place of dissolution as well as the undiminishing cause for this creation"

And, finally in the eleventh chapter of Bhagawad Gita, Arjuna is blessed with the vision of Ishwara in all his splendor.

divi surya sahasrasya
bhaved yugapthuthitha
yadi bhaa sadrisi saasyaad
bhaasathasya mahaatmanah  B.G Ch 11 Verse 12

"That great being (of Ishwara) stood shining forth in a splendor that equaled the glory of thousand suns rising simultaneously on the horizon"

And, where do we find such an Ishwara in the world?

ishwara Sarva Bhutaanaam
hriddese Arjuna thishtathi  B.G Ch 18 Verse 61

"The Ishwara dwells in the heart of every single being"

samoham sarva bhuteshu  B.G Ch 9 Verse 29

"I am equally present in all beings"

The above, in summary, is the view of Bhagawad Gita on the nature of Ishwara.

What is this world and what are we doing here?

Of the many words in Sanskrit Thesaurus for 'world', the one that fully encapsulates the nature of the world is 'jagat' which means 'that which comes into being and vanishes' (jaaayate gachate iti jagat').  Only when the impermanence of the worldly matter is well entrenched in the mind of a seeker can he follow the advice:

aagamaapaayino anithyah
Thaam thithikshaswa bhaaratha B.G Ch 2 Verse 14
"(The worldly experiences) are impermanent, coming into being and vanishing. Therefore, O Bhaaratha,  bear them with great fortitude"

Sri Krishna uses two other sanskrit terms, Prakriti and Kshetra, in Bhagawad Gita to refer to world. The English word 'Creation' owes its root to the Sankrit word 'Kru'. Prakriti is generally translated as 'Nature' but the literal translation is 'well created'. Bhagawad Gita offers a definition of Prakriti in the seventh chapter, in terms of what its composition is.

bhumiraaponalo vayuh
kham mano budhirevacha
ahankaara ideeyam me
bhinnaa prakritirashtatha B.G Ch. 7 , verse 4

"Earth, Water, Fire, Air, Space, Mind, Intellect and the 'I' Consciousness are the eight aspects of this Prakriti of mine"

From the gross physical sense, Prakriti comprises the three states of matter, energy and space. From the subtle non-physical sense, it comprises the 'I' consciousness as well as the emotional and thinking powers.

If this is Prakriti, then the question that arises is,  are each one of us part of Prakriti or of something else? Here is Sri Krishna's answer to the question:

idam sariram kauntheya
kshetram ityabhidiyate
etad yo vethi tham praahuhu
kshetranja iti tad vidah  B.G Ch. 13, Verse 2

"O Kauntheya, this mind-body complex is said to be the field (prakriti). The one who is aware of this mind-body complex, is the 'knower of the field' (or Purusha)"

Here is a very quick way to distinguish between what in us is  prakriti and what is purusha. Everything in us that we can address as 'mine' (e.g. my body, my mind, my intellect, my consciousness etc.) is prakriti. What we cannot do as such and can only address as 'I' is Purusha.

What does this Purusha do?

purusha prakritisthohi
bhungthe prakritijaan gunaan
kaaranam gunasangosya
sadasadyonijanmasu B.G Ch 13 Verse 22


"The Purusha, with its association to Prakriti, experiences the qualia (of Satwa, Rajas and Tamo gunas). Experience by the  Purusha of the qualia acts as a cause for the Purusha to be associated again with  aspects of prakriti that produce good (satwa guna dominant)  or evil (tamo guna dominant) experiences"

The qualia of the experiences that Prakriti delivers is classified into three, viz., Satwa (enlightening), Rajas (empowering) and Tamas (deluding). It is not necessary that every experience is exclusively one of these three, but rather is dominated by one of them. For Purusha to free itself from being drawn continuously into this endless chain of experiences, the first action is to associate more with Satwa dominant experiences and minimize the tamas domoinant experience. Bhagawad Gita has a lengthy discussion on this topic in the sixteenth and seventeenth chapters.

What does this world of cause and effect look like? To answer this question, Bhagawad Gita paints this very beautiful, though somewhat cryptic,  picture in the Fifteenth chapter:

urdhamoolam adha saakham
aswatham praahuravyayam
chandaamsi ysya parnaani
yastam veda sa veda vid  B.G Ch 15, Verse 1

"This (universe) is said to be like a never-diminishing Peepal tree that stands upside down with its (single) root on top and (multitude of) branches spreading downward. Its leaves are the verses of Veda. He who understands this is the (true) knower of Veda"

The enquiry into the root of the cause and effect chain of this universe leads to one single primary cause, which is the Brahman. From that root has sprung forth this world, with its many branches, each of which brings forth more branches. Though there is birth and death in it, in totality, this universe doesn't diminish but only transforms from one manifestation to the other. At the end of the branches are the leaves which are an end in itself, not causing more effects come forth. And, these leaves are the verses of veda  containing the knowledge of the self, Ishwara and the world.

To better appreciate the beauty of this metaphor,  please see below a picture of the leaf of a Peepal tree. Every leaf starts from a single stem, expands in the middle and trails off into a single point. Likewise, the chant of OM, starts with a singular tone, expands and then trails into silence. Only in that silence is the ultimate truth gets eloquently declared. 


Why should one care to know?

Sri Krishna offers a great reason, again in the thirteenth chapter,  on why one should care to know about the Self, Ishwara, the world and the inter-relationships between them.

ya evam vethi purusham
prakritim cha gunai saha
sarvathaa varthamaanopi
na sa bhuyobhi jaataye  B.G Ch 13, Verse 24

"He who comes to understand about the purusha (the indweller) and Prakriti (the world) along with Gunaas (the qualia that defines the type of experience), and is (able to abide in that) understanding continuously at all time, he is not born again"

The goal is to end this apparently eternal cycle of experience that are powered by the experience of Guna and the chain of cause and effects. And, this goal is achieved when one is established in the Right knowledge.